scripture pic

scripture pic
Showing posts with label System of Error. Show all posts
Showing posts with label System of Error. Show all posts

Monday, May 16, 2016

Killing Lazarus; Snowballing Systemized Error; the Non-Triumphal Entry and Caiaphas the Non-Prophet

Last week we looked at Systemized Error, the idea that there are intentional schemes and plans made to divide or cover up truth. One simple error can cause a huge amount of planned errors, in order to support the first error. Historically speaking, the one error of compromise over Jonathan Maccabee being appointed high priest, but staying to serve in the temple, led to many, many schemes to keep people worshipping in the temple. The one error that the religious people made caused a system of errors to cover up the first error. Always having to prove that a religious system is right is a sure sign that, at its roots, it is wrong. Later, after the Jews were kicked out of Jerusalem and the temple destroyed in 70 AD, more systematic error developed to erase Jesus as Messiah. As we have studied previously, nothing worked. Even the yeshiva curses recited three times a day did not prevent people from receiving Jesus as Lord and Savior. One of the schemes planned but not carried out was to kill Lazarus, as his resurrection was the miracle that drew many to follow Jesus. Caiaphas foretells sacrificing Jesus to save the nation, but Caiaphas did not mean “save” as unto eternal life, but “save” as in keeping the Romans from destroying Jerusalem and the temple. The plan to kill Jesus was inspired by the devil who was allowed to influence the religious leaders’ ideas because they were working to cover their initial error. If we can unravel the veins of wrong thinking, wrong teaching, and wrong practice, we will be able to understand what took place towards the end of Jesus’ life.

There is not much written about Lazarus, but we know from this context that he had two sisters and that he was ill. Mary was the person who later would anoint Jesus with perfume. Apparently Jesus knew Lazarus well and loved him, so it seems strange that when the sisters send for Jesus, Jesus does not go to Bethany to see them. If we remember our context, it was winter at the time of the Feast of Dedication, or Hanukkah, when Jesus was speaking in Jerusalem around Solomon’s porch. He was explaining the good shepherd and the hireling. Jesus leaves Jerusalem heading east, crosses the Jordan, and remains there until late winter or early spring. This was the desert, the place where the Essenes lived. The place where John baptized people, and the places the Prophets lived. Jesus spent his last few months in this region.

John 11:1 NOW A certain man named Lazarus was ill. He was of Bethany, the village where Mary and her sister Martha lived. 2 This Mary was the one who anointed the Lord with perfume and wiped His feet with her hair. It was her brother Lazarus who was [now] sick. 3 So the sisters sent to Him, saying, Lord, he whom You love [so well] is sick. 4 When Jesus received the message, He said, This sickness is not to end in death; but [on the contrary] it is to honor God and to promote His glory, that the Son of God may be glorified through (by) it. 5 Now Jesus loved Martha and her sister and Lazarus. [They were His dear friends, and He held them in loving esteem.] 6 Therefore [even] when He heard that Lazarus was sick, He still stayed two days longer in the same place where He was. 7 Then after that interval He said to His disciples, Let us go back again to Judea. 8 The disciples said to Him, Rabbi, the Jews only recently were intending and trying to stone You, and are You [thinking of] going back there again? 9 Jesus answered, Are there not twelve hours in the day? Anyone who walks about in the daytime does not stumble, because he sees [by] the light of this world. 10 But if anyone walks about in the night, he does stumble, because there is no light in him [the light is lacking to him].

Jesus wasn’t afraid of going back to Judea, because he knew he was walking in the light. This is a good point, and something we should consider. If we are doing what the Holy Spirit tells us to do, we are walking in the light. Therefore we should have no fear, we are walking in the day or light. Jesus then explains that Lazarus is dead, and that what is about to transpire will help them to believe.

John 11:11 He said these things, and then added, Our friend Lazarus is at rest and sleeping; but I am going there that I may awaken him out of his sleep. 12 The disciples answered, Lord, if he is sleeping, he will recover. 13 However, Jesus had spoken of his death, but they thought that He referred to falling into a refreshing and natural sleep. 14 So then Jesus told them plainly, Lazarus is dead, 15 And for your sake I am glad that I was not there; it will help you to believe (to trust and rely on Me). However, let us go to him. 16 Then Thomas, who was called the Twin, said to his fellow disciples, Let us go too, that we may die [be killed] along with Him.

Jesus got word Lazarus was ill, he waited in the desert two days, then “knew” he was dead, but by the time they got to Bethany, Lazarus had been in the grave four days. Jesus and the disciples were across the Jordan River, in Jordan and the desert regions, so it took time to cross the Jordan and travel over the mountains to get to Bethany.

John 11:17 So when Jesus arrived, He found that he [Lazarus] had already been in the tomb four days. 18 Bethany was near Jerusalem, only about two miles away, 19 And a considerable number of the Jews had gone out to see Martha and Mary to console them concerning their brother. 20 When Martha heard that Jesus was coming, she went to meet Him, while Mary remained sitting in the house. 21 Martha then said to Jesus, Master, if You had been here, my brother would not have died. 22 And even now I know that whatever You ask from God, He will grant it to You. 23 Jesus said to her, Your brother shall rise again.

Martha spoke accurately, Jesus said the same thing, however it was better that he wasn’t in Bethany otherwise Lazarus would not have died. The benefit was that people, including the disciples, would believe that Jesus was the Messiah when Lazarus arose. We have to imagine the way that people thought about Jesus. They knew he was doing miracles, like healing the blind, the deaf, the lame, and the mute. He was fulfilling Isaiah’s prophecies. He was an Essene, a Nazarene, and a Therapeutae, and was schooled in all three veins. But some of them had a hard time being sure he was the Messiah. He didn’t look particularly Messiah-ish. He didn’t look like Thor, and he didn’t have a charming sales pitch as to why people should follow him. And even though the miracles should have spoken for themselves, he lived among the Therapeutaes who were known healers, so maybe he just knew how to heal people. And while he had a great knowledge of spiritual matters, he was schooled among the Essenes, so maybe he was a scholarly person. His personal holiness could have spoken for itself because he was also of the Nazarenes, who lived a chaste and dedicated life to Yahweh, yet he ate with sinners and talked to sinners, and healed on the Sabbath. He was just a confusing guy to the people of that time.

We also have to keep in mind our history, as by this time nearly two hundred years had passed since the people had split up during the Hasmonean era, where the one group who later became known as Pharisees, stayed and served in the temple while the other people, who later became known as Essenes, Nazarenes, and Therapeutaes, left Jerusalem. The contention between those two groups fueled the Pharisees’ hate for Jesus and for the miracles he did. Remember who the lost sheep were? They were the people Jesus came to talk to, the Pharisees and Sadducees and all those who followed them. If we zoom out our view, we see the Pharisees and Sadducees in Jerusalem, thinking they are correct in their beliefs and fighting tooth and nail against anything or anyone who attempted to stop them from serving in the temple. Devising schemes and plans to “herd” all the simple people to their way of thinking, the religious leaders of the day continued to systemize error over error. But it is odd that the Essenes/Nazarenes/Therapeutaes were not living a contentious existence at all. The Pharisees and Sadducees were living in the dark and attempting to walk in darkness, stumbling along, while the Essenes/Nazarenes/Therapeutaes were walking in the light and not afraid of falling down.

Imagine the people of Jerusalem trying to decide whether to follow Jesus or stay with the Pharisees. The people were in such darkness, but they saw a great light, if the followed they would be condemned by the religious leaders, and that would make them outcasts from the religious system. Doesn’t it seem that religious systems systemize error in order to control people? Control is witchcraft enacted on people via manipulation, intimidation, and domination. Control has its own pathway leading to destruction.

Martha understood the resurrection, the time when all the dead in Christ would rise to heaven. This is what Jesus came to do, he came to set the captives free, taking the dead in hades, who were in the compartment of Abraham’s Bay, to paradise, to await the resurrection. This is why Jesus says that whoever believes on him shall never actually die. From the days of Adam until the day Jesus went into hades to witness to the imprisoned spirits, the righteous dead went to Abraham’s Bay and were separated by a chasm from the unrighteous dead. But after Jesus led captivity captive, and took back the keys to hell and death, he opened the way to paradise for the righteous, and he now gives those overcomers to eat of the tree of life in the midst of the paradise of God. When the door of heaven opens, the dead in Christ rise first, and the living righteous will join them in the air. The redeemed, purchased by Jesus’ blood, will join the other sons of God in heaven and prepare for Jesus’ return. We have studied all of these elements before, this is simply a recap so that we can understand what Jesus is saying to Martha. 

John 11:24 Martha replied, I know that he will rise again in the resurrection at the last day. 25 Jesus said to her, I am [Myself] the Resurrection and the Life. Whoever believes in (adheres to, trusts in, and relies on) Me, although he may die, yet he shall live; 26 And whoever continues to live and believes in (has faith in, cleaves to, and relies on) Me shall never [actually] die at all. Do you believe this? 27 She said to Him, Yes, Lord, I have believed [I do believe] that You are the Christ (the Messiah, the Anointed One), the Son of God, [even He] Who was to come into the world. [It is for Your coming that the world has waited.]

The world was waiting for Jesus to redeem the dead out of hades. The god of this world used to be in charge of hades, but he is not any longer. This was the first part of Jesus’ plan in coming to earth, to redeem the righteous dead out of hades and into paradise. The second part will be to make an army out of the select redeemed to establish his kingdom on earth.

Jesus had only gotten as far as the outskirts of Bethany, he hadn’t gone to Mary and Martha’s house yet. Martha had gone out to meet Jesus on the road. Now Martha went back to her home and told Mary Jesus was in town.

John 11:28 After she had said this, she went back and called her sister Mary, privately whispering to her, The Teacher is close at hand and is asking for you. 29 When she heard this, she sprang up quickly and went to Him. 30 Now Jesus had not yet entered the village, but was still at the same spot where Martha had met Him. 31 When the Jews who were sitting with her in the house and consoling her saw how hastily Mary had arisen and gone out, they followed her, supposing that she was going to the tomb to pour out her grief there. 32 When Mary came to the place where Jesus was and saw Him, she dropped down at His feet, saying to Him, Lord, if You had been here, my brother would not have died. 33 When Jesus saw her sobbing, and the Jews who came with her [also] sobbing, He was deeply moved in spirit and troubled. [He chafed in spirit and sighed and was disturbed.] 34 And He said, Where have you laid him? They said to Him, Lord, come and see. 35 Jesus wept.

Jesus was moved with compassion for the sadness of his friends. He knew their hearts were breaking. Now the entire group, Mary, Martha, the Jews who were mourning with them, Jesus, and his disciples, all went to Lazarus’ tomb. Notice the conversations of the Jews along the way, they knew Jesus wept because he loved them. They wondered if Jesus had been there whether Lazarus might not have died. They also note that Jesus had opened the eyes of the blind. They knew Jesus as a healer. Now they will come to know him as Messiah.

John 11:36 The Jews said, See how [tenderly] He loved him! 37 But some of them said, Could not He Who opened a blind man's eyes have prevented this man from dying? 38 Now Jesus, again sighing repeatedly and deeply disquieted, approached the tomb. It was a cave (a hole in the rock), and a boulder lay against [the entrance to close] it. 39 Jesus said, Take away the stone. Martha, the sister of the dead man, exclaimed, But Lord, by this time he [is decaying and] throws off an offensive odor, for he has been dead four days! 40 Jesus said to her, Did I not tell you and promise you that if you would believe and rely on Me, you would see the glory of God?

Jesus speaks to Martha as he had spoken to her earlier. She thought he was speaking about the far future, Jesus was actually speaking of the present time. If she believed on Him she would see the glory of God. Notice Jesus was sighing and deeply disquieted, his heart was moved with compassion. One of the keys to healing ministry is compassion on the part of the one who prays for the sick. Compassion energizes healing, as compassion comes from the heart waves of the one inspired by the Holy Spirit to stimulate the heart waves of the sick individual.

John 11:41 So they took away the stone. And Jesus lifted up His eyes and said, Father, I thank You that You have heard Me. 42 Yes, I know You always hear and listen to Me, but I have said this on account of and for the benefit of the people standing around, so that they may believe that You did send Me [that You have made Me Your Messenger]. 43 When He had said this, He shouted with a loud voice, Lazarus, come out!

Here is the communication between Jesus and the Heavenly Father. Jesus says: for the benefit of the people so they believe you sent me. The rain falls on the just and the unjust, the sun shines on the wicked and the good, we all live and then we die, good and bad happen to everyone. However, the dunamis, miracle working power, is always a witness to the unbelievers. After Jesus’ death the disciples use dunamis as a witnessing tool, this is what we sometimes miss. Healing is not about God wanting everyone to be healthy. Mistakenly we seem to think if people are not healthy they have done something wrong. Seeking healing for the sake of healing is wrong. That is the same wrong thinking of the Pharisees. Healing is about making disciples. But sickness falls on the just and the unjust, the wicked and the good, the believer and the unbeliever. Everyone dies, the first question is, where will an individual go when he/she dies? The second question is did he/she endure to the end, did he/she overcome? Those are not questions we on earth can answer, we can only guess. Rather, as the Essenes believe, we should simply endeavor to do our best. Lazarus walks out of the tomb. I’m sure he had a few stories to tell, being dead for four days and all. History claims that Lazarus never smiled after being in the grave, as he saw hades and knew where the unbelieving, unrighteous go.

John 11:44 And out walked the man who had been dead, his hands and feet wrapped in burial cloths (linen strips), and with a [burial] napkin bound around his face. Jesus said to them, Free him of the burial wrappings and let him go. 45 Upon seeing what Jesus had done, many of the Jews who had come with Mary believed in Him. [They trusted in Him and adhered to Him and relied on Him.] 46 But some of them went back to the Pharisees and told them what Jesus had done.

Did you notice verse 46? Some of the Jews, who just saw a man who they knew had been dead for four days, walk out of the tomb, went to tell the Pharisees. This is never a good thing, even if those Jews meant it as a witnessing tool for the unbelieving Pharisees. We cannot re-communicate the miracles we see to those who are unbelieving, with the expectation that they too will believe. People don’t change their hearts because someone else sees a miracle. Subsequently the Pharisees and the chief priests have a meeting with the Sanhedrin.

John 11:47 So the chief priests and Pharisees called a meeting of the council (the Sanhedrin) and said, What are we to do? For this Man performs many signs (evidences, miracles). 48 If we let Him alone to go on like this, everyone will believe in Him and adhere to Him, and the Romans will come and suppress and destroy and take away our [holy] place and our nation [our temple and city and our civil organization].

That is in fact what happens. In 70 AD the Zealots and Idumeans started a civil war with the Jews, and eventually the Romans took over all of Jerusalem, destroying the temple, and kicking the Jews out of the region. Caiaphas prophesies that Jesus should die for the nation, but Caiaphas is not a prophet. The actions of Caiaphas throughout the scriptures bear out that he is not a prophet, as the Pharisees lost the Holy Spirit when they decided to stay and serve in the temple. Caiaphas is simply stating that getting rid of Jesus is better for them, as they would be squashing an uprising and the Romans would not take the city and temple from them. Caiaphas’ words are fueled by his intent during Jesus’ trials taking place in the middle of the night. Also recognize that Caiaphas and Annas had temple guards, a Roman military force, at their disposal, so they could kill Jesus. This made Caiaphas and Annas and those who followed them look good to the Romans who were not interested in an uprising. All this scheming and planning was to eliminate Jesus to save themselves and the temple from Roman takeover. But this was/is part of Jesus’ plan to redeem the righteous dead from hades.

So while it seems that this meeting is a systemized conspiracy against Jesus, it was going to enable the exact thing Jesus came to do. Remember Jesus’ conversation with Peter after the mount of transfiguration? Jesus knew he came to die for the world, not just Jews, but for everyone who would believe. After the Holy Spirit infills the believers on the day of Pentecost, Caiaphas and the religious leaders arrest Peter and John for healing the lame man and talking to people about how healing is possible. 5,000 believed. Caiaphas and the other religious leaders are lectured by Peter and John and could not stop the disciples speaking Jesus’ name. Notice that Caiaphas keeps going in the wrong direction, never repenting. Systemized error surrounding the entire Parasitical set up in the temple caused constant misdirection in all matters, not just regarding Jesus. The Pharisees became so focused on what people did wrong that they forgot about what people did right. Healing on the Sabbath is not evil or breaking the Sabbath, it is doing good rather than evil.    

John 11:49 But one of them, Caiaphas, who was the high priest that year, declared, You know nothing at all! 50 Nor do you understand or reason out that it is expedient and better for your own welfare that one man should die on behalf of the people than that the whole nation should perish (be destroyed, ruined). 51 Now he did not say this simply of his own accord [he was not self-moved]; but being the high priest that year, he prophesied that Jesus was to die for the nation, [Isa 53:8.] 52 And not only for the nation but also for the purpose of uniting into one body the children of God who have been scattered far and wide. [Isa 49:6.] 53 So from that day on they took counsel and plotted together how they might put Him to death. 54 For that reason Jesus no longer appeared publicly among the Jews, but left there and retired to the district that borders on the wilderness (the desert), to a village called Ephraim, and there He stayed with the disciples.

The system of error was put in place to turn people against Jesus and to kill him, but notice Jesus’ actions, he is waiting for the right time to be killed. Again Jesus goes to the desert and stays with disciples. Jesus knows that he will be crucified when he goes back to Jerusalem and he is waiting for the Passover, meanwhile the Pharisees, priests, and Sanhedrin are plotting and systemizing error to keep people from believing that Jesus is Messiah. As far as these religious leaders know, all the “simple minded people” will follow after Jesus the healer, especially after Lazarus was raised from the dead after four days. The religious leaders don’t have any clue what is supposed to take place. For that matter the devil did not know either, because if he had known the mystery of the infilling of the Holy Spirit on all believers, he would never have crucified the Lord of Glory, 1 Cor 2:8. Even though the scheming of the Pharisees, priests, and Sanhedrin was inspired by the devil, and from an earthly vantage point it seemed like they were doing the Jews a favor keeping them from following Jesus, their plan freed the righteous dead from hades.

We’ve now come to the week before Nisan 14, the Passover. Passover was irrespective of the day of the week and this particular year it was on a Wednesday. They were watching for Jesus.

John 11:55 Now the Jewish Passover was at hand, and many from the country went up to Jerusalem in order that they might purify and consecrate themselves before the Passover. 56 So they kept looking for Jesus and questioned among themselves as they were standing about in the temple [area], What do you think? Will He not come to the Feast at all? 57 Now the chief priests and Pharisees had given orders that if anyone knew where He was, he should report it to them, so that they might arrest Him. AMP

On the 8th of Nisan Jesus comes back to Bethany to have dinner with Lazarus, Mary, and Martha. Seemingly, Lazarus was not suffering any ill effects from being dead for four days. Now Mary anoints Jesus’ feet with perfume. This is what John told us in the beginning of chapter 11. This is the same Mary.

John 12:1 SO SIX days before the Passover Feast, Jesus came to Bethany, where Lazarus was, who had died and whom He had raised from the dead. 2 So they made Him a supper; and Martha served, but Lazarus was one of those at the table with Him. 3 Mary took a pound of ointment of pure liquid nard [a rare perfume] that was very expensive, and she poured it on Jesus' feet and wiped them with her hair. And the whole house was filled with the fragrance of the perfume.

This anointing of Jesus’ feet took place six days before his crucifixion. Now Judas enters the picture. Several systems of error have been working out in Judas’ life. Judas was a thief, helping himself to the money he was to hold for the disciples. If we remember the ways of the Essenes and their community rules, upon entering the community one gives his money to the treasurer. If after one year that person wishes to leave the community he receives his money back in full. If after one year that person instead stays in the community, his money is merged with the common funds of the community. Judas was holding the purse of the twelve, which means that none of the twelve had his own money anymore. Judas helped himself to the money, which was dishonorable. This incident put a spotlight on Judas. His attitude about the perfume probably made some of the others think something was wrong. Jesus knew what Judas was doing but Judas didn’t think anyone knew. Selling Mary’s perfume (had she donated it) he would have taken some money to replenish the treasury and give a bit to the poor. Since that wasn’t going to happen he needed another plan. Selling Jesus to the Pharisees, priests, and Sanhedrin for money would help replenish the money he stole. Judas probably didn’t think Jesus would be killed. All of these systemized errors in Judas’ life built upon one another. He was stealing money, so he condemns Mary for her extravagance, appearing to look concerned for the poor. He condemns her with the intent to take the perfume and sell it to replenish money he stole, but Jesus tells him to leave her alone. Because everyone knew the religious leaders were looking for Jesus, Judas went to strike a deal for money. This pattern of error continues in Judas even after Jesus’ death. The devil knows how to lead people into intentional systematic error. 

John 12:4 But Judas Iscariot, the one of His disciples who was about to betray Him, said, 5 Why was this perfume not sold for 300 denarii [a year's wages for an ordinary workman] and that [money] given to the poor (the destitute)? 6 Now he did not say this because he cared for the poor but because he was a thief; and having the bag (the money box, the purse of the Twelve), he took for himself what was put into it [pilfering the collections]. 7 But Jesus said, Let her alone. It was [intended] that she should keep it for the time of My preparation for burial. [She has kept it that she might have it for the time of My embalming.] 8 You always have the poor with you, but you do not always have Me.

The bursar was a very important office in the Essene communities, and that was Judas’ job among the twelve. Judas would have bought food and clothes for the twelve disciples and Jesus, and he would have been thought of as a banker or accountant. Because none of the twelve would have had their own money, no one would have been overfed while someone else was left hungry or cold. They shared all things in common, just like we saw the first century believers do as soon as they repented and believed on Jesus, they acted like Essenes. This was the way people started to live, in community.  

It is interesting that people heard Jesus was in Bethany, and a great crowd of Jews went there to see Jesus as well as Lazarus. The religious leaders put the word out and now they knew where Jesus was. But remember that we studied a while back how the crowds grew and grew throughout Jesus’ ministry. As Jesus healed more and more people, more and more Jews followed him. The crowds grew out of control, especially in the eyes of religious leaders who were not gaining followers. Between this and the fear that the Romans would take Jerusalem from the Jews, the religious leaders had to stop this movement.

John 12:9 Now a great crowd of the Jews heard that He was at Bethany, and they came there, not only because of Jesus but that they also might see Lazarus, whom He had raised from the dead. 10 So the chief priests planned to put Lazarus to death also, 11 Because on account of him many of the Jews were going away [were withdrawing from and leaving the Judeans] and believing in and adhering to Jesus.

Because Lazarus had been raised from the dead people were leaving the religious order, so the chief priests planned to kill Lazarus. Let’s think this through. They planned to kill Jesus six days before Passover. Now they plan to kill Lazarus as well. It seems like the bad ideas just keep on multiplying. Once Jesus was dead, Lazarus wouldn’t be raised up again, so it seems a safe bet that the plan was to kill Jesus first. Lazarus was a living testament to the power Jesus had over the grave, and people were leaving Judea to follow Jesus, who had been spending quite a bit of time in the desert with disciples there. Bethany is only two miles east of Jerusalem, so this was not a long journey for the average person. Today however, people would not walk two miles, but drive instead. Because the Jews were hunting Lazarus, he left for Cyprus and was eventually appointed bishop of Kition by Paul and Barnabas. We don’t know what happened to Martha or Mary but they may have left Bethany for Cypress with Lazarus. 

There is a period of a few days here before Jesus rides into Jerusalem on a donkey on the 10th or 11th of Nisan. Jesus goes to Bethany and eats dinner with his friends. A huge crowd goes to Bethany to see Jesus. Then he sends the disciples out to get a donkey and he rides into Jerusalem. As Jesus comes down from Bethany, the Jews who witnessed Lazarus rising form the dead kept on telling people what happened. And as we know from the other gospel accounts, Jesus rides a donkey into the city, he weeps over Jerusalem, goes into the temple, overturns the tables in the temple, is questioned by the religious leaders, he heals the blind and lame, and as he leaves Jerusalem for Bethany, he curses a fig tree. Jesus goes back to Jerusalem the next day, passing by the withered fig tree, teaches in the temple, and is questioned by religious leaders again. It doesn’t seem like a triumphal entry or a joyous occasion. However in hindsight, we can say that he rode into Jerusalem as a future King, took authority over the evil money schemes in the temple (another system of error that had developed over time), healed people and taught in the outer courts of the temple. He then left the religious leaders in a mess. 

John 12:12 The next day a vast crowd of those who had come to the Passover Feast heard that Jesus was coming to Jerusalem. 13 So they took branches of palm trees and went out to meet Him. And as they went, they kept shouting, Hosanna! Blessed is He and praise to Him Who comes in the name of the Lord, even the King of Israel! [Ps 118:26.] 14 And Jesus, having found a young donkey, rode upon it, [just] as it is written in the Scriptures, 15 Do not fear, O Daughter of Zion! Look! Your King is coming, sitting on a donkey's colt! [Zech 9:9.] 16 His disciples did not understand and could not comprehend the meaning of these things at first; but when Jesus was glorified and exalted, they remembered that these things had been written about Him and had been done to Him. 17 The group that had been with Jesus when He called Lazarus out of the tomb and raised him from among the dead kept telling it [bearing witness] to others. 18 It was for this reason that the crowd went out to meet Him, because they had heard that He had performed this sign (proof, miracle). 19 Then the Pharisees said among themselves, You see how futile your efforts are and how you accomplish nothing. See! The whole world is running after Him! AMP

Let’s look at verse 19 in the Greek TR Interlinear.

John 12:19


 oi(

3588
 hoi


 ou@n
therefore
3767
 oún


 Farisai=oi
The  Pharisees
5330
 Pharisaíoi


 ei@pon
said
2036
 eípon


 pro\$
among
4314
 prós


 e(autou/$
themselves
1438
 heautoús



 Qewrei=te
Perceive  ye
2334
 Theœreíte


 o%ti
how
3754
 hóti


 ou)k

3756
 ouk


 w)felei=te

5623
 œpheleíte


 ou)de/n:
nothing
3762
 oudén;


 i&de
behold
1492
 íde


 o(
the
3588
 ho



 ko/smo$
world
2889
 kósmos


 o)pi/sw
after
3694
 opísœ


 au)tou=
him
846
 autoú


 a)ph=lqen
is  gone
565
 ap¢¡lthen

(Interlinear Transliterated Bible (TR Edition). Copyright © 2011 by Biblesoft, Inc. All rights reserved. [For more detail see the full copyright page.])

Notice that the untranslated words here renders this more emphatic. Perceive how nothing prevails, nothing. Nothing was stopping people from following Jesus. This tells us that there was at least one plan that the Pharisees had in place that was not working. There may have been several plans attempting to stop people from following Jesus. But no matter how many schemes religious leaders come up with to keep people from Jesus, people will find Jesus if they want to.


Given the idea that the religious leaders were deceptive, crooked, and evil, it is hard to believe that anybody actually wanted to follow them; but the “spell” of manipulation kept people bound. As we see from history, one error leads to many schemes, systemizing error, so that people can’t tell what the truth is. This is why from hindsight it is hard to believe there are still people today who wish to act like the Pharisees, binding people under the law. Clearly history reveals a lot of dirty secrets among the religious leaders, and we are hard pressed to simply give them all a pass. It is important to understand that systematic error is not only a religious problem, but a cultural, societal, and political problem. It takes time to unravel these schemes, but if we do, we can be set free from continual error. Then we can walk in the day and in the light, and not be afraid to stumble. 

Monday, May 9, 2016

The System of Error; Beware of the Bandwagon; Posers and Transformers Dividing Humans

The systemtization of various pathways of social, political, religious, or moral beliefs are intentionally created so that people have to choose sides. Humans then, becoming divided, create chaos and cloud over our original purpose, which is a relationship with the Creator, Yahweh. Veins of systemized error run through social media attempting to ensnare and gather more followers. When factions start jockeying for their positions, humans tend to become further divided and that distracts us from walking in love toward one another. Have you ever heard a person say that they believe something just because someone with a “big name” said it?  Many people hop on the bandwagon because they assume that the others already marching along cannot all be wrong. Instead, the current trend or trends may very well be systemized error intended for the destruction of mankind. Have you ever seen social media posts where people behave emotionally unstable, hating either a political candidate, or religious leader? Yet all people have really seen is fake media articles, click bait, and meme’s? The naive person who “likes and shares” everything supporting their ideas has only heard what the media or the internet has broadcast, rather than listening and researching the politician or preacher. That is a trap for all of us to avoid. Simply put, Yahweh requires us to know a bit more about a subject if we are going to tell others what we think, so that we can be unashamed and stand approved before God. We cannot announce our opinions of who has cooties if we have not done the research as to cooties themselves, and their potential health hazards. The god of this world has laid traps for us, so let’s try to uncover some of the schemes we are dealing with.

The definition for systematic error is as follows:
Systematic Error: noun, Statistics.
1.     a persistent error that cannot be attributed to chance.
For an error to become persistent it would indicate that there is a perpetual motion to it. Take for example the first century Jews who rejected Jesus. Some religious leaders rejected Jesus and the general population chose sides. As we previously studied, Jesus was of the Essene/Nazarene/Therapeutae order which separated from the temple and followed the Holy Spirit.  While the Pharisees compromised and stayed with the temple, forsaking the Holy Spirit at the time of the Hasmonean era. When the Pharisees made their decision to forsake Jesus, other people followed those religious men, rather than the Holy Spirit or Jesus the Messiah. This rallying of people to join in the Pharisees opinion is the start of systemizing error. This is how the Pharisees could gather people to demand Barabbas be turned loosed rather than Jesus. This is why it seemed that Pharisees and Sadducees followed Jesus around trying to trick him. They were systemizing error. Who was behind it? The god of this world, or as Jesus called him, the prince of this world. But men carried out the plan of intentional error.   

To start systemizing error, there has to be a group of humans leading and swaying the population. There is a word in the Greek that is used three times in three consecutive verses that sums up the intentional workers of systemized error. The word metaschematizo means transform, transfigure, or change the outer appearance. In other words to systemize error, there are some who disguise themselves for the express purpose of fooling others into behaving erroneously; thereby starting a movement of error among many people. The Pharisees had been disguising themselves as spiritual leaders for nearly two hundred years before Jesus’ ministry started. They were not true spiritual leaders; in fact, as we have previously noted, they did not even have any prophets. The Prophets were of the Essene/Nazarene/Therapeutae order. So imagine this, the true spiritual leaders were not in Jerusalem, serving in the temple, yet the people took the Pharisees side to believe what these corrupt men were saying. We know that they were corrupt as Jesus exposed many of their evil ways, but somehow people jumped on the Barabbas band wagon. We should strongly consider whether we fall into this type of behavior in spiritual, political, or social matters. Let’s read what Paul says about people masquerading in order to trick or fool others.

2 Cor 11:13-15 For such are false apostles, deceitful workers, transforming themselves into the apostles of Christ.14 And no marvel; for Satan himself is transformed into an angel of light.15 Therefore it is no great thing if his ministers also be transformed as the ministers of righteousness; whose end shall be according to their works. KJV

2 Cor 11:13-15 For such men are false apostles [spurious, counterfeits], deceitful workmen, masquerading as apostles (special messengers) of Christ (the Messiah). 14 And it is no wonder, for Satan himself masquerades as an angel of light; 15 So it is not surprising if his servants also masquerade as ministers of righteousness. [But] their end will correspond with their deeds. AMP

2 Cor 11:12-15 And I'm not changing my position on this. I'd die before taking your money. I'm giving nobody grounds for lumping me in with those money-grubbing "preachers," vaunting themselves as something special. 13 They're a sorry bunch — pseudo-apostles, lying preachers, crooked workers — posing as Christ's agents but sham to the core. 14 And no wonder! Satan does it all the time, dressing up as a beautiful angel of light. 15 So it shouldn't surprise us when his servants masquerade as servants of God. But they're not getting by with anything. They'll pay for it in the end. (from THE MESSAGE: The Bible in Contemporary Language © 2002 by Eugene H. Peterson. All rights reserved.)

2 Cor 11:13G3588 G1063For G5108such ones G5570are false apostles, G2040[2workers G13861deceitful], G3345changing appearance G1519into G652apostles G5547of Christ.
 14G2532For G3756it is not G2298surprising G1473[3himself G10631for G3588 G45672Satan] G3345to change appearance G1519into G32an angel G5457of light.
 15G3756It is not G3173a great thing G3767then G1499if even G3588 G1249his servants G1473 G3345change appearance G5613as G1249servants G1343of righteousness; G3739whom G3588the G5056end G1510.8.3will be G2596according to G3588 G2041their works. G1473

3345
LSJ Gloss: μετασχηματίζω to change the form of
Dodson: μετασχηματίζω I change the outward appearance, transfigure, adapt I change the outward appearance (the dress, the form of presentment) of something, transfigure; I adapt.
Strong's: μετασχηματίζω to transfigure or disguise; figuratively, to apply (by accommodation)
Derivation: from G3326 and a derivative ofG4976; KJV Usage: transfer, transform (self).
Thayer: 1) to change the figure of, to transform
For Synonyms see entry G5863
μετασχηματίζω  metaschēmatizō  met-askh-ay-mat-id'-zo From G3326 and a derivative of G4976; to transfigure or disguise; figuratively to apply (by accommodation)

Posers. Eminence Front. Facade. So we’ve established that there are people disguising themselves to intentionally lead people astray, the devil himself does the same thing. Paul says their end, the end of the masqueraders, will be according to their works. But we bear the responsibility of our actions as well. While we may not lose our salvation by being led astray, we may lose rewards; and if we have taken to social media to announce our erroneous opinions, we bear the responsibility of leading others astray. Shame on us for not being mindful of what we say and do. Take note of Deuteronomy.

Deut 27:18 Cursed is he who misleads a blind man on his way. All the people shall say, Amen.  AMP

Deut 27:18G1944Accursed is G3588the G4105one misleading G5185the blind G1722in G3598the way. G2532And G2046[4shall say G39561all G35882the G29923people], G1096May it be

Moses and the Levites made these announcements of curses just like the Essenes pronounced curses as recorded in the Dead Sea Scrolls. While we may not ever intentionally cause a blind person to be misled, what if we cause spiritually blind people to be misled, or immature people to be misled? Simply because we joined a bandwagon on an erroneous path and called others to follow.

We have studied the word planao #4105 before, when we studied people who become addicted to delusion. Those people who are addicted to delusion enjoy systemizing error. We won’t take the time to review that entire message but we will look at this word and some of its variations to understand trends and movements, and how not to be fooled. 


NT:4105 planao (plan-ah'-o); from NT:4106; to (properly, cause to) roam (from safety, truth, or virtue):KJV - go astray, deceive, err, seduce, wander, be out of the way.

Manasseh was a king who was addicted to delusion and he misled people intentionally. Here the word planao is translated “misled”, but let’s also note verse 10 as well.

2Kings 21: 9G2532And G3756they did not G191hearken. G2532And G*Manasseh G4105misled G1473them G3588 G4160to do G3588the G4190wicked thing G1722in G3788the eyes G2962of the lord G5228above G3588the G1484nations G3739which G853the lord removed G2962 G575in front G4383 G3588of the G5207sons G*of Israel

2 Kings 21:9-10 But they would not listen; and Manasseh seduced them to do more evil than the nations did whom the Lord destroyed before the Israelites! 10 And the Lord said through His servants the prophets: AMP

Manasseh seduced the people, he systematically led people in the wrong direction, but take a look at verse 10. Yahweh speaks to the Prophets. Remember the Prophets were the Zedeks, descended from Shem and Eber’s school in Jebus. The same school Isaac and Jacob went to and that Abraham helped finance. The very same group of people who were later known as the Essenes/Nazarenes/Therapeutaes. What did Manasseh do?

2 Kings 21:1-8 Manasseh was twelve years old when he became king. He ruled for fifty-five years in Jerusalem. His mother's name was Hephzibah. 2 In God's judgment he was a bad king — an evil king. He reintroduced all the moral rot and spiritual corruption that had been scoured from the country when God dispossessed the pagan nations in favor of the children of Israel. 3 He rebuilt all the sex-and-religion shrines that his father Hezekiah had torn down, and he built altars and phallic images for the sex god Baal and sex goddess Asherah, exactly what Ahaz king of Israel had done. He worshiped the cosmic powers, taking orders from the constellations. 4 He even built these pagan altars in The Temple of God, the very Jerusalem Temple dedicated exclusively by God's decree ("in Jerusalem I place my Name") to God's Name. 5 And he built shrines to the cosmic powers and placed them in both courtyards of The Temple of God. 6 He burned his own son in a sacrificial offering. He practiced black magic and fortunetelling. He held séances and consulted spirits from the underworld. Much evil — in God's judgment, a career in evil. And God was angry. 7 As a last straw he placed the carved image of the sex goddess Asherah in The Temple of God, a flagrant and provocative violation of God's well-known statement to both David and Solomon, "In this Temple and in this city Jerusalem, my choice out of all the tribes of Israel, I place my Name — exclusively and forever. 8 Never again will I let my people Israel wander off from this land I gave to their ancestors. But here's the condition: They must keep everything I've commanded in the instructions my servant Moses passed on to them."  (from THE MESSAGE: The Bible in Contemporary Language © 2002 by Eugene H. Peterson. All rights reserved.)

In fifty-five years Manasseh twisted the nation in many different directions. One man, addicted to delusion, systemized enough error to destroy the southern kingdom. Did people follow Manasseh’s error? Yes. The god of this world didn’t need hundreds of people to start a false undertaking, he only needed one guy to lead thousands and thousands astray. But Yahweh was still speaking to the Prophets. So people had a choice, whose group would they follow, Manasseh’s or the Prophet’s? If one rotten apple spoils the entire bunch, we can see that the devil doesn’t need much to steer people in the wrong direction. One charismatic leader can lead or mislead many people. Paul says this:

Gal 6:7-8 Do not be deceived and deluded and misled; God will not allow Himself to be sneered at (scorned, disdained, or mocked by mere pretensions or professions, or by His precepts being set aside.) [He inevitably deludes himself who attempts to delude God.] For whatever a man sows, that and that only is what he will reap. 8 For he who sows to his own flesh (lower nature, sensuality) will from the flesh reap decay and ruin and destruction, but he who sows to the Spirit will from the Spirit reap eternal life. AMP

What are we sowing becomes an important question for our own personal benefit. Are we caught up in a chaotic movement and sowing discord, or are we living above the culture and social systems and personally pursuing Spiritual matters? Jesus warns us not to be misled by a prophetess who leads people into doing the wrong things. While this seems obvious to us looking in from the outside, on the inside of a situation like this people can be misled. This is a great understanding for us as to why there are satanic orders that people engage in. People are seduced into believing something is truth when it may not be. In this case, the seduction included physical pleasures which is connecting the body to the error, not just the mind.  

Rev 2:20 But I have this against you: that you tolerate the woman Jezebel, who calls herself a prophetess [claiming to be inspired], and who is teaching and leading astray my servants and beguiling them into practicing sexual vice and eating food sacrificed to idols. [1 Kings 16:31; 2 Kings 9:22,30.] AMP

It is clearly evident, that there are many ways we can be led into error; bad leaders, false prophets, and false teachers. Paul fought a good fight against a Jewish clique pushing circumcision. That is another system of error. While it seems religiously correct, it is actually a systematic approach to push people into religious bondage. But eating with non-Jews should not have even been considered wrong, as Jesus did the same. The Message makes this passage very clear.

Gal 2:12-13 Here's the situation. Earlier, before certain persons had come from James, Peter regularly ate with the non-Jews. But when that conservative group came from Jerusalem, he cautiously pulled back and put as much distance as he could manage between himself and his non-Jewish friends. That's how fearful he was of the conservative Jewish clique that's been pushing the old system of circumcision. 13 Unfortunately, the rest of the Jews in the Antioch church joined in that hypocrisy so that even Barnabas was swept along in the charade. (from THE MESSAGE: The Bible in Contemporary Language © 2002 by Eugene H. Peterson. All rights reserved.)

Notice, the group of people promoting error caused others to feel uncomfortable with their liberty in Christ. Sometimes that condemning attitude causes people to follow those pious accusers. The conservative Jewish clique who pushed circumcision made people feel condemned for eating with non-Jews. Peter is made fearful of the deluded religious deceivers, then changes his behavior. Barnabas also becomes afraid of the deluded Jews and he jumps on the bandwagon as well. There were others in Antioch who started to do the same.  Paul does a good job pointing this out for us. He says that none of them were maintaining a steady straight course, and that is what systemized error attempts to do to us, it pushes us onto a crooked path. Look at how Paul corrects the situation.   

Gal 2:14-16  But when I saw that they were not maintaining a steady, straight course according to the Message, I spoke up to Peter in front of them all: "If you, a Jew, live like a non-Jew when you're not being observed by the watchdogs from Jerusalem, what right do you have to require non-Jews to conform to Jewish customs just to make a favorable impression on your old Jerusalem cronies?" We Jews know that we have no advantage of birth over "non-Jewish sinners." 16 We know very well that we are not set right with God by rule-keeping but only through personal faith in Jesus Christ. How do we know? We tried it — and we had the best system of rules the world has ever seen! Convinced that no human being can please God by self-improvement, we believed in Jesus as the Messiah so that we might be set right before God by trusting in the Messiah, not by trying to be good. (from THE MESSAGE: The Bible in Contemporary Language © 2002 by Eugene H. Peterson. All rights reserved.)

Here is our charge, speak up! Paul confronted the systemized error loudly and in front of everyone. He squashed that crooked road Peter and Barnabas started to walk down by speaking the truth. It didn’t make Paul popular, but it did break the scheme of the devil. Paul didn’t talk to others about what happened until after he confronted Peter and Barnabas in front of those present at that time. Then Paul wrote to the Galatians and told them what was going on. That way, if the deluded religious Jews came to their town making their people feel uncomfortable for eating with non-Jews, and pushing circumcision, the Galatians would already know that that behavior is wrong and they would not join that movement.

Is it possible to know the scriptures and to misrepresent them? Peter tells us it is. That should be no surprise as the devil knows the scriptures too. He quoted them to Jesus during his temptations. He also altered the direction Yahweh gave Adam when speaking to Eve in Genesis 3. Therefore it is possible that some systemization of error occurs within the institutions we entrust to teach us the Bible because the devil knows what the truth is and how to misconstrue it. Another derivative of planao, plane, is used by Peter to warn us.

2 Peter3:17G1473You G3767then, G27beloved, G4267foreknowing, G5442guard G2443that G3361not G3588by the G3588[2of the G1133unlawful ones G41061delusion] G4879having been led away, G1601you should fall from G3588your own G2398 G4740steadfastness!

NT:4106 plane (plan'-ay); feminine of NT:4108 (as abstractly); objectively, fraudulence; subjectively, a straying from orthodoxy or piety:KJV - deceit, to deceive, delusion, error.

Let’s read this in context. It is interesting to note Peter’s warning after reading Paul’s reproof of Peter and Barnabas. Peter walked with Jesus, and he understood the battle Jesus faced. If we remember, a few weeks ago we looked at who the lost sheep were that Jesus was sent to, they were the Pharisees and those that the Pharisees led astray. Those were the people Jesus spoke to, not the Essenes, Nazarenes, or Therapeutaes as he grew up with them and was schooled by them. So Peter’s perspective is that of continuing Jesus’ message to the lost sheep. Paul was a Pharisee, he had been a lost sheep, and had to unlearn all the things he was schooled in. As we noted, Paul took time in the desert with the Damascus community to learn the Essene/Nazarene/Therapeutae ways. Peter though gave Paul quite a bit of credit, noting that Paul was given much wisdom.   

2 Peter 3:14-18 So, my dear friends, since this is what you have to look forward to, do your very best to be found living at your best, in purity and peace. 15 Interpret our Master's patient restraint for what it is: salvation. Our good brother Paul, who was given much wisdom in these matters, 16 refers to this in all his letters, and has written you essentially the same thing. Some things Paul writes are difficult to understand. Irresponsible people who don't know what they are talking about twist them every which way. They do it to the rest of the Scriptures, too, destroying themselves as they do it. 17 But you, friends, are well-warned. Be on guard lest you lose your footing and get swept off your feet by these lawless and loose-talking teachers. 18 Grow in grace and understanding of our Master and Savior, Jesus Christ. Glory to the Master, now and forever! Yes! (from THE MESSAGE: The Bible in Contemporary Language © 2002 by Eugene H. Peterson. All rights reserved.)

Paul was a lost sheep who was now teaching others, yet people were twisting what he was saying. Paul spent many years studying, so the comparison Peter is making is that the ones twisting Paul’s words are ignorant. The Jews who fought so hard against this new movement were illiterate. Notice verse 16 in the literal Greek, Peter says that some people are illiterate and unstable, and they make crooked the things Paul says, as well as the rest of the scriptures.

2 Peter 3:16G5613as G2532also G1722in G3956all G3588the G1992letters, G2980speaking G1722in G1473them G4012concerning G3778these things; G1722in G3739which G1510.2.3[2are G14253hard to comprehend G51001some things], G3739which G3588the G261illiterate G2532and G793unstable G4761make crooked, G5613as G2532also G3588the G3062rest G1124of scriptures, G4314to G3588 G2398their own G1473 G684destruction

The systemization of error within the church can be from illiteracy. Seminaries don’t always make people literate, they mold the students’ perception according to their core religious beliefs. This puts blinders and sunglasses on students, who then present the same lopsided information to others. The narcissistic illiterate gather followers and another religious denomination is born. Again, it is our responsibility to dig out the truth, to study to show ourselves approved so that we can rightly divide the word of truth. While Peter gives people a pass, calling them illiterate, or ignorant and unstable, many are intentionally deluded and spreading the system of error, just like the Jewish clique that made Peter fearful. They had a plan to grow their movement, and tried to get others on their bandwagon. There are people today still expounding those ideas.

Another variation of planao is planos. Planos seems to imply deceivers are a moving target with their contrived error. They are seducers that create multiple systemized erroneous pathways, or posers who change their arguments for their audience.  In looking at 1 Timothy, we see something bigger. A seducing spirit inhabits a poser who is addicted to delusion, and that poser, via the seducing spirit, causes people to leave the faith. That happens all the time. We get upset over people forsaking Yahweh but we don’t understand the systemized plot.

NT:4108 planos (plan'-os); of uncertain affinity; roving (as a tramp), i.e. (by implication) an impostor or misleader; KJV - deceiver, seducing.
(Biblesoft's New Exhaustive Strong's Numbers and Concordance with Expanded Greek-Hebrew Dictionary. Copyright © 1994, 2003, 2006 Biblesoft, Inc. and International Bible Translators, Inc.)

1 Tim 4:1 Now the Spirit speaketh expressly, that in the latter times some shall depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits, and doctrines of devils; KJV

1 Tim 4:1 BUT THE [Holy] Spirit distinctly and expressly declares that in latter times some will turn away from the faith, giving attention to deluding and seducing spirits and doctrines that demons teach, AMP

1 Tim 4:1-10 The Spirit makes it clear that as time goes on, some are going to give up on the faith and chase after demonic illusions put forth by professional liars. 2 These liars have lied so well and for so long that they've lost their capacity for truth. 3 They will tell you not to get married. They'll tell you not to eat this or that food — perfectly good food God created to be eaten heartily and with thanksgiving by Christians! 4 Everything God created is good, and to be received with thanks. Nothing is to be sneered at and thrown out. 5 God's Word and our prayers make every item in creation holy. (from THE MESSAGE: The Bible in Contemporary Language © 2002 by Eugene H. Peterson. All rights reserved.)

It is not unlikely that these doctrines of devils change and morph and move, to capture more people in their web. It only takes one leader to create a bandwagon for others to follow. And as Ambassadors of the Most High God we will be looked at and scrutinized by others. Are we falling victim to schemes of error?  

Paul encourages us on how to live in freedom and liberty. While specifically he is speaking of the law and of circumcision, we can also understand his words in a broader sense. Even though we have the freedom to voice our opinions, we are not forced to voice our opinions. We need wisdom. We need to live in the Spirit.

Gal 5:13-18 It is absolutely clear that God has called you to a free life. Just make sure that you don't use this freedom as an excuse to do whatever you want to do and destroy your freedom. Rather, use your freedom to serve one another in love; that's how freedom grows. 14 For everything we know about God's Word is summed up in a single sentence: Love others as you love yourself. That's an act of true freedom. 15 If you bite and ravage each other, watch out — in no time at all you will be annihilating each other, and where will your precious freedom be then?
16 My counsel is this: Live freely, animated and motivated by God's Spirit. Then you won't feed the compulsions of selfishness. 17 For there is a root of sinful self-interest in us that is at odds with a free spirit, just as the free spirit is incompatible with selfishness. These two ways of life are antithetical, so that you cannot live at times one way and at times another way according to how you feel on any given day. 18 Why don't you choose to be led by the Spirit and so escape the erratic compulsions of a law-dominated existence? (from THE MESSAGE: The Bible in Contemporary Language © 2002 by Eugene H. Peterson. All rights reserved.)

Professional liars and seducers are creating veins of error for people to follow, divide over, and fight over. What we feed on is what we become, and if we sow into systematic error we reap systematic destruction. That has been the plan for mankind all along. From Genesis 3, with the subtle suggestions and misrepresentations in the garden, to the temptations of Jesus, to the Pharisees condemning Christians over who to eat with and circumcision. The bait has been laid out in social media, to tempt us to voice opinions. The noise is loud. The divisions are deep. The systematic approach to split mankind with error has been created in social, cultural, political, and religious organizations. It is a plan, not a haphazard path to destruction. How will we respond? Will we live above the fracas or join in the brawl? It is better to leave the bandwagon behind and live in love being led by the Holy Spirit.